Page 1 of 1
Best Diesel for 28
Posted: Sep 7th, '07, 10:20
by buzzk
A friend of mine has a gas powered 1977 FBC 28. He's talking about putting Diesels in. What's the best engines for this installation? Thanks Buzz
Posted: Sep 7th, '07, 12:15
by In Memory Walter K
The Faithful have installed Yanmars and Steyrs if I am not mistaken, with very positive results. Will surely end any Ethanol problems if he does. Don't remember any Cummins installations, but am probably wrong. I'm sure 28 owners will be chiming in real soon with the details. Walter
Posted: Sep 7th, '07, 15:33
by STeveZ
I have Cummins B210's and ZF transmissions. So far so good @ 1500 hours. Survey shots from two years ago...
This pic from last spring's bulkhead replacement shows you the risers that were added to accomodate the coolant cap. A little material appears to have been routed out of the hatches as well.
Posted: Sep 7th, '07, 18:17
by buzzk
Steve what kind of speeds do you get with the 210? His is a 1977 model and I think his has a lower deck than the later models. Does yours have the higher deck? Thanks Buzz
Posted: Sep 7th, '07, 18:37
by Hyena Love
Best is rather subjective. Depending on budget and access to maint, I think the list includes Volvos, Yanmars, Cummins, and Styers. My thinking was - Volvo too many $$$$, Cummins Ok, Styers too new and no support, Yanmars were just right.
Yanmar 240 will "likely" fit under the low hatch models, but measure, measure, measure. Shaft size and positioning plays an important role. My hatches would close with Yanmars, but I raised the hatches to accommidate insulation and because my hatches tended to sag a bit when folks jump on them. Interestingly, the insulation really seemed to stiffen the hatches.
Posted: Sep 7th, '07, 19:06
by Kevin
This one could get interesting. Might just sit back and watch for a while.
Posted: Sep 7th, '07, 20:07
by scot
Learn something every day. I didn't realize a 28 could hold 6B's. Judging from the pictures I guess the turbo versions would be too big for the engine bay / hatch cover?
Steve I hope you like the engines because I doubt you will EVER wear them out. If Cummins ever built a live-forever engine those are it, you could change the oil every 5 or 6 years....but only if you want to.
Posted: Sep 7th, '07, 20:19
by Harry Babb
Scot
Take a really closer look..........those engines are turboed........but not after cooled
Harry Babb
Posted: Sep 7th, '07, 21:12
by Thums Up
We have a pair of yan mar 240's in our boat in Costa Rica. They are great so far, cruise all day at 25 knots. Only like 500hr so far.
Posted: Sep 7th, '07, 21:54
by scot
Harry they were hidding from me. And...was under the impression the 210hp was the natural hp version? I guess I was wrong on both accounts, Not the first time, not even the first time today!
Thanks,
Posted: Sep 7th, '07, 22:18
by Charlie
Look at the new yanmar using the BMW block. We had one at the Mid-Atlantic Rendezvous. Looked very nice. Also look at Nanni. They have some very clean installations in 31B's and the 200Hp engine that pushes a 31 at 26kts should make the 28B really fly.
www.bertramrendezvous.com has links to the yanmar dealer and the Nanni guys.
Good Luck
Posted: Sep 7th, '07, 23:28
by Ironman
My freind has the Cummins 210s in his 31... Really sweet... & thrifty. Cruises at 22k at 2200 rpms.
Gotta be a great CHOICE FOR A B28 . KNOWING THEYLL FIIT,Turbos & no aftercoolers
Wayne
No Turbo on 6B?
Posted: Sep 8th, '07, 08:39
by Capt. Mike Holmes
Scot, actually, if you take the turbo off the 6B, as in industrial applications, it drops to I think 140 hp. I'm sure they run forever at that rating.
Posted: Sep 8th, '07, 09:01
by Bruce
I would hold off the Yanmar BY series (made by BMW) till 08'.
They have had some problems as with every new design and have started and stopped production numerous times.
I would wait till all the bugs are out.
Posted: Sep 9th, '07, 09:05
by STeveZ
Buzz,
Here's some performance figures from last year. Having blasted, filled, sealed and painted the bottom this spring doesn't seem to have had much effect on these numbers.
'83 B28 FBC w/ Cummins 6BTA 210's:
RPM's / Knots
800 / 6.0 (Idle)
1200 / 8.0
1800 / 15.5
2100 / 20.2
2300 / 21.6
2400 / 22.5
2700 / 26.5 (WOT)
Note: Knots x 1.15 = MPH
Starboard engine topped out at and maintained 190 degrees, port engine stayed under 185
Props are 20 x 19
Posted: Sep 10th, '07, 06:30
by buzzk
Bruce, what's the deal with the Steyrs in the Bertram 28? Thanks Buzz
Cummins
Posted: Sep 10th, '07, 07:18
by Jack
I have 4BTA's in my 28 Bahia Mar. Top end about 30 kts, cruise 24-26 kts. Very economical.
Posted: Sep 10th, '07, 08:14
by buzzk
Jack, I've been told the 4b's are not smooth at idle, is this true? How do yours run at idle? I like the Cummins, I have a pair of 6bta in my Bertram 33. Thanks Buzz
Posted: Sep 10th, '07, 08:38
by In Memory Walter K
Even 6bt's need to be at 650 rpm's and not lower or they start to rumble. Walter
Posted: Sep 10th, '07, 09:02
by CaptPatrick
Buzz,
All 4 cylinder engines in the same class are a bit more noisy than their 6 cylinder counterparts. Easier to balance 6 than 4...
Br,
Patrick
Posted: Sep 10th, '07, 11:08
by Jack
As Patrick said, the 4BTAs are not as smooth as 6's when idling, but their not terrible. I have cushions on the engine boxes that help deaden the sound alot.