Page 1 of 1

I am not sure Uncle Vic would approve...

Posted: Jan 2nd, '19, 18:09
by Carl

Re: I am not sure Uncle Vic would approve...

Posted: Jan 2nd, '19, 18:44
by David Davidson
In my experience of using both D4s and D6s in Superyacht tenders they are good motors but let down by bad electronics. In one year we had to replace 3 complete (twin) throttle quadrants and ECUs from 4 engines. Volvo simply could not find the problems.

After those tenders we chose Steyr engines for the replacements. Had similar problems with those, but less frequent.

....and that’s why I chose good old fashioned mechanical Yanmars for my B31 rebuild last year!!!

Re: I am not sure Uncle Vic would approve...

Posted: Jan 2nd, '19, 20:43
by Tony Meola
Volvo parts are not cheap. I guess they figured the fuel savings using 4 cylinder Volvo made up for the added parts expense.

Re: I am not sure Uncle Vic would approve...

Posted: Jan 2nd, '19, 20:45
by Bruce
The 31 I repowered with D4's turned out to be a battle wagon and a very nice install, but 3 computers per engine, like has been mentioned, they were replaced multiple times.

While this was years ago, I hope they have the computer issue figured out or Tropic is in for it.

Re: I am not sure Uncle Vic would approve...

Posted: Jan 3rd, '19, 00:57
by Yannis
It says they chose them because reliability was their primary concern...

If I want reliability I go Japanese. Every time.

Re: I am not sure Uncle Vic would approve...

Posted: Jan 3rd, '19, 06:55
by Carl
Just funny how they went from simple old tech screaming 4cyl Detroit Diesels to Volvo's.

In my opinion Volvo marine motors have been synonymous with over-engineered and over priced parts.

I'm sure they did their homework...

Re: I am not sure Uncle Vic would approve...

Posted: Jan 3rd, '19, 11:20
by David Davidson
On paper they look good. They're modern, and the Volvo brand is strong. Maybe someone in an office somewhere made the decision!

Re: I am not sure Uncle Vic would approve...

Posted: Jan 3rd, '19, 16:33
by saburke17
i had a TAMD41P 4 banger and that thing would shake the boat apart at idle, when i first bought her i freaked out and thought something was wrong. 200 rps higher and she purred like kitten

Re: I am not sure Uncle Vic would approve...

Posted: Jan 6th, '19, 10:02
by Dug
Well, many of us will get to see first hand how it is working come this August. I am guessing UV would not approve. But I am looking forward to seeing for myself!

Dug

Re: I am not sure Uncle Vic would approve...

Posted: Jan 7th, '19, 08:08
by Carl
While I am not sure UV would approve...I have a feeling he would not hold back from jumping on a quieter, quicker 31 over a screaming DD.

Heck, they make break down and cost a bundle to get them back up and running when parts come in...but that would not be his problem.